Robustness Analysis of Speed Control Method to Drive AC/DC Motor

- Irianto, Farid Dwi Murdianto, Epyk Sunarno, - Yusra


The development of industry in Indonesia has an impact on the increasing use of electric motors. There are two main types of motors, DC motor, and AC motor. Both motors have different characteristics according to the settings and controls. Proportional Integral control and Proportional Integral Derivative control are used for setting motor speed. This control has control parameters that are Kp, Ti, and Td. These parameters are derived from derivatives of mathematical calculations on the conventional PI and PID methods. However, determining these parameters can also be done with other methods. There are 4 PI and PID tuning methods t used to get effective control parameters and have the best performance: Ziegler Nichols tuning method, Chien Servo 1 tuning method, Chien Regulator 1 tuning method, and the last is mathematical calculation theory. The result is the best tuning method for DC Motor is the Chien Regulator 1 tuning method with a value of Kp = 5,601 and Ki = 56,01. And for induction motor, the best tuning method with PI control is Chien servo 1 tuning method with Kp = 0,433 and Ki = 4,163, and for PID control, the best tuning method is the Ziegler Nichols tuning method with Kp = 1,4833, Ki = 98,89 and Kd = 0,052, and get a steady-state error approximately is 4%. And when given the interference to the rotor of the motor, the Ziegler Nichols tuning method is the fastest to return the response to the steady state condition.


Induction motor; DC motor; PI controller; PID controller; chien regulator; chien Servo; Ziegler Nichols.

Full Text:



Stephen J Chapman, Electric Machinery Fundamentals, 4th ed., New York: McGraw Hill Book Companies, p. 380, 2005.

Katsuhiko Ogata, Modern Control Engineering, Fift Edition, p. 567, 2010.

Ye Naung, Schagun Anatolii, Ye Htet Lin, “Speed Control of DC Motor by Using Neural Network Parameter Tuner for PI-Controller,” IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, p. 2152, 2019.

Maycon Chimini Bosco, Jacqueline Jordan Guedes, Marcelo Favoretto Castoldi, Alessandro Goedtel, Emerson Ravazzi Pires da Silva, Luiz Fransisco Sanches Buzachero, “Estimation of Parameters and Tuning of a Speed PI of Permanent Magnet DC Motor Using Differential Evolution,” IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics,” 2017.

Devendra Potnuru, J.S.V. Siva Kumar, “Design of a Front-End DC-DC Converter for a Permanent Magnet DC Motor using Fuzzy Gain Scheduling,” IEEE International Conference on Power, Control, Signals and Instrumentation Engineering (ICPCSI), 2017, p.1502.

Dil Kumar T.R, Mija S.J, “Dynamic SMC Control Scheme with Adaptive Tuned PID Controller for Speed Control of DC Motor,” IEEE International Conference on Industrial Technology (ICIT), 2015, p. 187.

Ibtihel JAZIRI, Lotfi CHARAABI, Khaled JELASSI, “A closed Loop DC Motor Control using low-cost single-board microcontroller based on embedded Linux,” IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, 2016.

Ahmed J. Fattah, Dr. Ikhlas Abdel-Qader, P.E., “Performance and Comparison Analysis of Speed Control of Induction Motors using Improved Hybrid PID-Fuzzy Controller,” IEEE International Conference on Electro/Information Technology (EIT), 2015.

Divya Asija, “Speed Control of Induction Motor Using Fuzzy-PI Controller,” IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, vol. 15: p. 460, 2010.

Fayez F. M. El-Sousy, “Design and Implementation of 2DOF I-PD Controller for Indirect Field Orientation Control Induction Machine Drive System,” Electronics Research Institute, ERI, DOKKI, CAIRO, EGYPT, p. 1112, 2001.

Greeshma Sarah John, Abhilash T Vijayan, “Anti-Windup PI Controller for Speed Control of Brushless DC Motor,” International Conference on Power, Control, Signals and Instrumentation Engineering (ICPCSI), 2017, p. 1068.

Dileep Kumar, R.A. Gupta, Nitin Gupta, “Minimization of Current Ripple and Overshoot in Four Switch Three-Phase Inverter fed BLDC Motor using Tracking Anti-windup PI Controller,” IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, 2017.

Piush Kumar, Vineeta Agarwal, “A Study of Conventional and Fuzzy PI Controller CSI Fed Induction Motor,” IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, 2010.

Bapayya Naidu Kommula, Venkata Reddy Kota,” Perfomance Evaluation of Hybrid Fuzzy PI Speed Controller for Brushless DC Motor for Electric Vehicle Applocation,” Conference on Power, Control, Communication and Computational Technologies for Suistanable Growth (PCCCTSG), 2015, p. 266.

Novie Ayub Windarko, Ony Asrarul Qudsi, Anang Tjahjono, Dimas Okky A, Mauridhi Hery Purnomo,”Optimized PI Constant for Current Controller of Grid Connected Inverter with LCL Filter Using Genetic Algorithm,” Makassar International Conference on Electrical Engineering and Informatics (MICEEI), 2014, p. 9.

CAO Fengwen, WANG Yiwang, “Study and Application of Fuzzy PID Control-Based for FFU Motor Speed Regulation Control System,” IEEE International Electric Machines & Drives Conference (IEMDC), 2011, p. 160.

WU Zhenlong, LI Donghai, WANG Lingmei,” Control of the Superheated Steam Temperature: A Comparison Study between PID and Fractional Order PID Controller,” Proceedings of the 35th Chinese Control Conference, 2016, p. 10521.

Arman Jaya, Era Purwanto, Melinda Badriatul Fauziah, Farid Dwi Murdianto, Gigih Prabowo, Muhammad Rizani Rusli, “Design of PID-Fuzzy for Speed Control of Brushless DC Motor in Dynamic Electric Vehicle to Improve Steady-State Performance,” International Electronics Symposium on Engineering Technology and Application (IES-ETA), p. 179, 2017.

Rinki Maurya, Manisha Bhandari, “Design of Optimal PID (FOPID) controller for Linear system,” International Conference on Micro-Electronics and Telecommunication Engineering, 2016, p. 439.

Zhenbo Pan, Fei Dong, Jiwen Zhao, Lijun Wang, Hui Wang, Yinyi Feng, “Combined Resonant Controller and Two-Degree-of-Freedom PID Controller for PMLSM Current Harmonics Suppression,” IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, 2017.

Wang Xin, Li Ran, Wang Yanghua, Peng Yong, Qin Bin, “Self-tuning PID Controller with Variable Parameters Based on Particle Swarm Optimization,” Third International Conference on Intelligent System Design and Engineering Application, 2013, p. 1264.

S. Janarthanan, K.N.Thirukkuralkani, S.Vijayachitra, “Performance Analysis of Non-Integer Order PID Controller for Liquid Level Control of Conical Tank System,” ICICES2014-S.A.Engineering College, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India, 2014.

Renny Rakhmawati, Suhariningsih, Farid Dwi Murdianto, Janitra Hilmyvarafi Farrasbyan, “Performance Robustness of PID Controller in Buck Converter for Cooling System,” International Seminar on Application for Technology of Information and Communication (iSemantic), p.127, 2018.

Samart Singh, R. Mitra, “Comparative Analysis of Robustness of Optimally Offline Tuned PID Controller and Fuzzy Supervised PID Controller,” Porceedings of 2014 RAECS UIET Panjab University Chandigarh, 2014.

Rohit Bhimte, Kalyani Bhole, Pritesh Shah,”Fractional order fuzzy PID Controller for a roatary servo system,” Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Trends in Electronics and Informatics (ICOEI), 2018, P. 538.

D K Sambariya, R. Prasad, D. Birla, “Design and Performance Analysis of PID based Controller for SMIB Power System using Firefly Algorithm,” Proceeding of 2015 RAECS UIET Panjab University Chandigarh, 2015.

K. Sundaravadivu, B.Arun, K. Saravanan, ”Design of Fractional Order PID Controller for Liquid Level Control of Spherical Tank,” IEEE International Conference on Control System, Computing and Engineering, 2011, p. 291.

Indhana Sudiharto, Epyk Sunarno, Farid Dwi Murdianto, Desy Nanda Kurniasari, “Robustness Analysis of PID Controller to Constant Output Power with Dynamic Load Condition in DC Nanogrid System,” 3rd International Conference on Information Technology, Information Systems and Electrical Engineering (ICITISEE), Yogyakarta, Indonesia, 2018, p. 402.

Moh. Zaenal Efendi, Farid Dwi Murdianto, Hayat Nur Baweani, “Robustness Analysis of PID-Cuckoo Search Algorithm to Voltage Control in Three Phase of Synchronous Generator with Dynamic Load Condition,” International Electronics Symposium on Engineering Technology and Applications (IES-ETA), p. 133, 2018.

Vimala Vindhya, Venkat Reddy,”PID-Fuzzy Logic Hybrid Controller for a Digitally Controlled DC-DC Converter,” International Conference on Green Computing, Communication and Conservation of Energy (ICGCE), 2013, p. 362.

Reza Sedagheh Maskan Sadigh,”Optimizing PID Controller Coefficients Using Fractional Order Based on Intelligent Optimization Algorithms for Quadcopter,” International Conference on Robotics and Mechatronics (IcRoM), 2018, p. 146.

Dong Hwa Kim,”Tuning of PID Controller For Dead time Process Using Immune Based Multiobjective,” IEEE Mid-Summer Workshop on Soft Computing in Industrial Applications Helsinki University of Technology, Espoo, Finland, 2005.

Yan-Jun Wu, Young-Gook Jung, Young-Cheol Lim, “Auto-Tuning Fuzzy PD Control Scheme for Output Voltage Control of Three-phase Z-source Inverter,” IEEE International Symposium on Industrial Electronics, 2012, p. 222.

Prashant S Malik, Sujay S Gawas, Imran Altaf Patel, Ninad P Parsekar, dkk, “Transient Response Improvement of DC-to-DC Converter by Using Auto-tuned PID Controller,” Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Inventive Communication and Computational Technologies (ICICCT),2018, p. 546.

Subhash Chander,”Auto-tuned, Discrete PID Controller for DC—DC Converter for fast transient response,” India International Conference on Power Electronics (IICPE), 2011.

Dong Hwa Kim, Won Pyo Hong, Jin ILL Park, “Auto-Tuning of Reference Model Based PID Controller Using Immune Algorithm,” Proceedings of the 2002 Congress on Evolutionary Computation, 2002.

Hamed Shahsavari Alavije, Mahdi Akhbar,” Auto-tuning PID Controller for Low-Cost Fault Tolerant Motor Drive of Electric Vehicle,” 4th Annual International Power Electronics, Drive Systems and Technologies Conference, 2013, p. 38.

Suppachai Howimanporn, Sasithorn Chookaew, Warin Sootkaneung, “Design of PLC for Water Level Control Employing Swarm Optimization-Based PID Gain Scheduling,” International Conference on Control and Robots (ICCR), 2018, p. 63.

Reza Ezuan Samin, Lee Ming Jie, Mohd. Anwar Zawawi,” PID Implementation of Heating Tank in Mini Automation Plant Using Programmable Logic Controller (PLC),” International Conference on Electrical, Control and Computer Engineering, 2011.

Bambang Dwi Argo, Yusuf Hendrawan, Dimas Firmanda Al Riza, Anung Nugroho Jaya Laksono, “Optimization of PID Controller Parameters on Flow Rate Control System Using Multiple Effect Evaporator Particle Swarm Optimization,” International Journal on Anvanced Science Engineering Information Technology, vol. 5: p. 62, 2015.

Aminurrashid Noordin, Mohd Ariffanan Mohd Basri, Zaharuddin Mohamed, Amar Faiz Zainal Abidin, “Modelling and PSO Fine-tuned PID Control of Quadrator UAV,” International Journal on Anvanced Science Engineering Information Technology, vol. 7: p. 1367, 2017.

Mahmud Iwan Solihin, Lee Fook Tack, Moey Leap Kean, “Tuning of PID Controller Using Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO),” Procedding of the International Conference on Anvanced Science, Engineering and Information Technology, 2011, p. 458.



  • There are currently no refbacks.

Published by INSIGHT - Indonesian Society for Knowledge and Human Development